Dispassion
Ian Goddard
igoddard at EROLS.COM
Tue Jun 11 11:45:08 CDT 1996
At 03:27 PM 6/10/96 GMT, egodust wrote:
>>
>> When we "circumscribe," or draw a circle, and call the area inside it
>> "area A," we've defined area A. Yet in so doing we also define the
>> complementary external area ~A that surround the internal area.
>> A <=> ~A. We cannot define internal A more than we
>> simultaneously define the external ~A.
>
> This analogy can only work if your talking about drawing a circle on an
> infinte plane of space or [hypothetically] some singular and homogenous
> substance.
> Otherwise it fails--at least from the wholistic perspective. That is,
> although the Particular Effect is never anything intrinsically segregated
> from the Universal Cause, to consider that it is the Cause *unto itself*,
> whole and complete, is erroneous. If that were the case, the ego Effect,
> *unto itself*, could be relied upon unreservedly.
IAN: I am not sure I follow what you mean by "cause" as it's used above,
or what "it" is when you say "..to consider that it is the Cause..."
A thing, A, is not a cause unto itself in that it cannot arise
independent of ~A, but I am not sure that addresses your point.
> My only point of contention [in this debate] is that logic, being a
> product of thought, cannot have an ultimate value (viz.: that it functions
> as a strategic *means* to an end; that once it's accomplished its mission,
> it has no further 'executive' purpose. And furthermore, that upon one's
> a rriving at the threshold to the final Release {renunciation of ego},
> it may actually prove to be an obstacle!).
IAN: The only obstacle is the thought "there are obstacles."
An obstacle can stand between distant points (if we assume a
point is confined to its internal area), but I Am is always
right here right now, never over there and then. 'Obstacle'
implies separation and duality -- that is the fallacy.
Law of Identity: A is A, relative to not-A. A = {A, ~A}
Law of Nonidentity: If there is 100% A, there is 0% A. A = ~A
absolute reality: http://www.erols.com/igoddard/reality.html
More information about the Advaita-l mailing list