Some Vedic sacrifices of this century

Anand Hudli anandhudli at HOTMAIL.COM
Thu Jan 13 14:13:37 CST 2000

On Wed, 12 Jan 2000 17:18:54 -0600, Sankaran Jayanarayanan
<kartik at ECE.UTEXAS.EDU> wrote:

>1) The Apastamba shrauta suutra which says that it is to be performed by
>one who has the desire for svarga.
>2) Some others (YAGYavalkya, etc.) who say that it a nitya karma for the
>wealthy alone and NOT for the poor.
>Considering both the above declarations, why can we not say the injunction
>is applicable for one who has the desire for heaven AND the required
>The dharma shAstras are clear that the nitya karmas enjoined on a person
>are to be performed without desire. Why the mention of desire in the
>shrauta suutra if it is an obligatory duty? Isn't it blatantly out of
>context to mention desire regarding one's dharma?
>If the shrauta suutra is the CHIEF smR^iti to consult in this regard, why
>should it say "svargakamo yajeta" at all?

 You hit the nail on its head with this one. But, not to worry,
 MadhusUdana comes to the rescue! He provides the answer in his
 gUDhArthadIpikA commentary on the gItA, chapter 17.  In brief,
 YaGYas can be nitya karmas or kAmya karmas depending on how
 one does them.

 First of all, the yaGYas from agnihotra to the jyotishhToma are
 of two types, nitya and kAmya,  as MadhusUdana says, "agnihotra-
  yaGYo dvividhaH kAmyo nityashcha |"

 A yaGYa may be performed  either in a sAttvika way or in a
 rAjasika way. (The gItA also mentions the tAmasika yaGYa but that
 is not relevant here.)

 When one performs yaGYas with the understanding that he is doing them
 because "they have to be done and if they are impossible to do then
 I may do them by the alternative rites", these are nitya karmas. In
 a YaGYa done as a nitya karma, one is not doing it with any specific
 desire and may do the YaGYa by an alternative (or inferior) method
 if the regular method is impossible to follow. For example, the
 vaishvAnarI ishhTi, as an alternative, can take the place of the

 When one performs YaGYas with a desire for heaven, etc., that becomes
 a kAmya YaGYa, which is classified as a rAjasika YaGYa by the gItA.
 Here, the significant difference in the performance is that the YaGYa
 MUST be performed by the primary method mentioned in the shAstras.
 The alternative method must NEVER be used.

 This means if one is a poor dvija he is off the hook as far as the
 expensive yaGYas are concerned. He is not required to do them but only
 the alternative. If one is a dvija who can afford the expenses,
 he is *required* to do them. If, in some instance, such a man cannot
 possibly do them he can get by with the alternative YaGYa.

 But, for a man who has the desire indicated as the result of a YaGYa,
 there is no leeway. He has to follow the shAstras to the letter in doing
 the YaGYas.

 This is entirely consistent with YAGYavalkya smR^iti 126 and the
 mitAxarA commentary on it that I posted earlier.


bhava shankara deshikame sharaNam

Archives :
Help     : Email to listmaster at
Options  : To leave the list send a mail to
           listserv at with
           SIGNOFF ADVAITA-L in the body.

More information about the Advaita-l mailing list