[Advaita-l] Ishwara srushti - shruti bhAshya sammata

[Venkatesh Murthy]

Namaste

Yes Jeeva Kruta Srushti theory is a back door entry to Moksha itself. It is
a secret door to Moksha is the statement of Praachina Acharyas like Swami
Vidyaranya and not some modern Hippy Swami saying when he is smoking and
drunk. How can we reject it?

Bhaamati has clearly said Ishwara has nothing or ZERO role in Avidyaa
dealings. He is always Nitya Shuddha Buddha Paramaatma. Therefore Rama Raya
Kavi has correctly said Bhaamati Prasthana is saying Ishwara is
Nirupaadhika Brahma only. In Sankara Bhashya also he has many times used
Ishwara word for Nitya Shudda Brahma only. I can find the references but
you will say you cannot see them.

If Ishwara as Nirupaadhika Brahma  is untouched by Avidyaa there is only
one suspect for being Srushti Kartaa and it is Jeeva. He has created all
this Dream with Avidyaa.



On Thu, Aug 3, 2017 at 4:40 PM, Bhaskar YR via Advaita-l <
advaita-l at lists.advaita-vedanta.org> wrote:

> praNAms
> Hare Krishna
>
> Kindly pardon me, it is really sickening to note sometimes in Advaita
> vedAnta  nAstika or chArvAka vAda gaining  a back door entry though it may
> not be the intention of propagators of jeeva bhrAnti srushti instead of
> vedAnta / bhAshya pradipAdita or sammata brahma abhinna nimittOpadAna
> kAraNa srushti  or Ishwara hetuka srushti or vedAnta maryAda srushti.
>
> As per vedAnta, shankara prakriyAdhArita Advaita vedAnta, brahma is the
> jagat kAraNa, it is brahman (chetana) alone prior to srushti thought about
> srushti and does the srushti kriya  with its intrinsic powers like
> sarvajnatvaM and sarvashaktitvaM.
>
> Shruti vehemently announces that : sarvaM khalvidaM brahma tajjalAn iti
> shAntyupaaseeta.  bhAshyakAra clarifies : sarvamidaM vikArajAtaM brahmaiva
> tajjatvAt, tallatvAt, tadanatvAccha.  And Itareya quite explicit in this
> regard : AtmA vA edam eka evAgra Aseet and there is nothing apart from it
> na anyat kiMchana mishat sa Ekshata imaannu lokAnnu srujA iti, sa
> emAllokAnasrujata, sa EkshAmchakre prANamasrujata prashna shruti, mundaka :
> yaH sarvajnaH sarvavidyasya jnAnamayaM tapaH, tasmAt etat brahma nAma rUpaM
> annaM cha jAyate.
>
> Based on these shruti statements ( and other numerous shruti quotes with
> regard to brahma kAratvaM ) bhAshyakAra in the very second sUtra
> janmAdyasya yatha comprehensively again  clarifies  that neither pradhAna
> nor anU nor saMsAri jeeva are the cause of this jagat.  Please refer these
> bhAshya quotes :
>
> // quote //
>
> Asya jagatO nAmarUpAbhyAM vyAkrutasya aneka katrubhOkta saMyuktasya prati
> niyata desha kAla nimitta kriyAphalAshrayasya manasApi achintya
> rachanArUpasya janma sthiti bhangaM yataH sarvajnAt, sarvashakteH kAraNAt
> bhavati ' tad brahma' iti vAkya sheshaH....
>
> //  unquote //
>
> And it would be worthy to note that in continuation bhAshyakAra clarifies
> what I said above :
>
> // quote //
>
> Na yathOkta visheshaNasya jagataH yathOktavisheshaNaM IshvaraM muktvA
> anyataH pradhAnAt achetanAt, aNubhyaH, abhavAt, 'SAMSAARINO' vA utpattyAdi
> saMbhAvayitum shakyaM.
>
> // unquote //
>
>
> And finally didn't shankara himself says Ishwara's upAdhi, omniscience and
> omnipotence etc. is kevala avidyAkruta in araHbhaNAdhikaraNa sUtra bhAshya
> ??  yes, when one realizes  the paramArtha jnana i.e. idaM sarvaM
> yadayamAtA, brahmaivedaM sarvaM, AtmaivedaM sarvaM, neha nAnAsti kiMchana
> etc. the Ishwara the ruler, the jagat which is being ruled, the lordship of
> Ishwara over the jeeva-s etc. is dvaita only which is avidyA only due to
> parichinna drushti that splits in the form of  nAnA which will be
> completely eradicated by the dawn of Atmaikatva jnAna.  And it does not
> anyway propagate the 'anishta' theory of jeeva bhraAti srushti' which is
> directly doing the shruti hAni, siddhAnta hAni and bhAshya viruddha as well.
>
> Hari Hari Hari Bol!!!
> bhaskar
> _______________________________________________
> Archives: http://lists.advaita-vedanta.org/archives/advaita-l/
> http://blog.gmane.org/gmane.culture.religion.advaita
>
> To unsubscribe or change your options:
> http://lists.advaita-vedanta.org/cgi-bin/listinfo/advaita-l
>
> For assistance, contact:
> listmaster at advaita-vedanta.org
>



-- 
Regards

-Venkatesh