[Advaita-l] [advaitin] SSSS on the controversy between mulav7idya and abhavarupa - directly and simply explained as per SSSS

[Bhaskar YR]

praNAms Sudhanshu prabhuji
Hare Krishna

What is silly here in asking why "only" ShAnkar BhAshya?


  *   Asking why only shankara in understanding shankara bhAshya, is silly and ridiculous.  After all you should know that we are trying to understand shankara vedAnta through what bhAshyakAra himself said.  If anyone doubts it's necessity and throwing questions it is kevala 'bAlisha'.

How did you get indoctrinated by this idea that you should not refer anything other than ShAnkar BhAshya.


  *   First you should come out of clutches of vyAkhyAna influence,  then only you would realize the importance of bhAshya and ONLY bhAshya.  And at that point of time only you would stop raising questions / doubts like this and making nonsense comments like indoctrination/brainwashing etc.  Till that time you can enjoy your rubbish comments like this on those who want to follow shankara and ONLY shankara.  Do I have to remind you that personal attacks like this is the sign of desperation ??

Then why on earth do you read what SSS ji wrote.


  *   Because Sri SSS does not ask us to read / study what he writes but asking us to 'go back home'.  If you don't understand this simple task given by him, I don't know how can I help you!!??

That is not ShAnkar BhAshya either.


  *   You can have your own grand imagination on what he writes and advocates that is not my problem.

And if you read SSS to understand ShAnkar BhAshya better, what stops you in extending the same argument to those who read other works to understand bhAshya better.


?     Ayyo raama!!  Where I have said Sri SSS started his own prakriya to understand shankara OTOH Sri SSS asked us to stick to mUlabhAshya when these vyAkhyAnakAra-s themselves indulging in street battle and do not accept one another's interpretations and opinions.  Do you think his call is fanaticism and an attempt of indoctrination??  Please be sensible before passing the comments like this.

Restricting yourself to only ShAnkar BhAshya without a cogent explanation therefor shows your fanaticism. Otherwise explain your presumption.


?    Asking the question about importance of sticking to shankara bhAshya in shankara sampradaya!!??   This is one of the most rubbish comments I have ever heard in shankara sampradaya does not deserve any reply.

//Unfortunately those who have opted exclusive jnAna mArga not exception to this hysterical blabbering//

I am afraid you have confused jnAna-mArga for intellectual lethargy and fanaticism.


  *   Again you are out of your mind when passing the comments like this.  Please go back and read what I said under what context about the exclusive jnAna mArga followers and their involvement in belittling other guru-s.

As Michael ji said -- "let time be the jury, let time decide". This is an example of intellectual lethargy, when despite becoming answerless, you trod the same path.


?     Sri MCC prabhuji is really patient despite your repeated attacks and sarcasms on him.  Perhaps, other way of looking at it is  they have better things to do then answering your queries loaded with mere dry logic.  And you can also note that they are not answerable to each and every nuisance of yours.


  *   Finally being a good friend of mine ( barring the differences ) I am requesting you restrain yourself from personal attacks.  You would be better served in your purpose of your stay in this group.


Hari Hari Hari Bol!!!
bhaskar