[Advaita-l] [advaitin] SSSS on the controversy between mulav7idya and abhavarupa - directly and simply explained as per SSSS

[Sudhanshu Shekhar]

Namaste Bhaskar ji.

First you should come out of clutches of vyAkhyAna influence,  then only
> you would realize the importance of bhAshya and ONLY bhAshya.  And at that
> point of time only you would stop raising questions / doubts like this and
> making nonsense comments like indoctrination/brainwashing etc.  Till that
> time you can enjoy your rubbish comments like this on those who want to
> follow shankara and ONLY shankara.  Do I have to remind you that personal
> attacks like this is the sign of desperation ??
>

Sir. None is undermining the importance of bhAshya. But why should one
restrict to "only" bhAshya? I mean if some text helps me to understand
bhAshya - why should it not be studied? Do you mean we should not study
vArtika, Naishkarmya Siddhi? If yes, then why SSS ji commented on NS?

//Because Sri SSS does not ask us to read / study what he writes but asking
us to ‘go back home’.  If you don’t understand this simple task given by
him, I don’t know how can I help you!!??//

But how is Naishkamrya Siddhi "home"? If you are restricting only to
BhAshya, why are you reading NS?


 You can have your own grand imagination on what he writes and advocates
> that is not my problem.
>

This is a non-answer.


> Ø     Ayyo raama!!  Where I have said Sri SSS started his own prakriya to
> understand shankara OTOH Sri SSS asked us to stick to mUlabhAshya when
> these vyAkhyAnakAra-s themselves indulging in street battle and do not
> accept one another’s interpretations and opinions.
>

This can be said in one line by SSS ji - read bhAshya only. Why did he
write 10000 pages? What was the need? Go to bhAshya - is sufficient.

 //Do you think his call is fanaticism and an attempt of indoctrination??
Please be sensible before passing the comments like this.//

Yes Bhaskar ji. It is fanaticism and indoctrination because it kills your
intellectual capacity by being blind.


>  Asking the question about importance of sticking to shankara bhAshya in
> shankara sampradaya!!??   This is one of the most rubbish comments I have
> ever heard in shankara sampradaya does not deserve any reply.
>

Sir ji. Some basic class-8 grammar book may please be revisited. Question
is not about the importance of sticking to bHAshya. Question is about
sticking to *only *bhAshya*.*

Rest of your comments are being ignored.

If you can, answer the arguments adduced which show gross misunderstanding
by SSS ji of fundamental concepts of pratiyogitA-avachchhedaktaA,
bhAvarUpatva of ajnAna proved through anumAna, pratyaksha and NAsadIya
Shruti-pramANa and numerous bhAshya and vArtika reference.

Regards.
Sudhanshu Shekhar.