[Advaita-l] [advaitin] Is pot-abhAva bhAvarUpa

[Sudhanshu Shekhar]

Namaste Bhaskar ji.

Shortly, I was wondering how Sri Sudhanshu prabhuji holding POT in his hand
> and trying to prove bhAvarUpa mUlAvidyA 😊 If I remember correctly Sri
> Venkataraghavan prabhuji, few years back, had written some post on ghata
> bhAshya, it is more of pre-existence of kArya in kAraNa and it is not about
> brahmAshrita mUlAvidyA and IMO, here bhAshyakAra has no intention of
> proving pre-existense of bhAvarUpa mUlAvidyA!!  I don’t know how our
> tArkika Sri SudhAnshu prabhuji is trying to prove apple holding orange in
> his hand!! 😊  Ghata bhAshya rather a good source to understand kArya
> ananyatva with kAraNa  and kArya (pot) ever existence with kAraNa (clay).
> Simply it is all about mAya satkArya vAda, the existence of kArya in the
> kAraNa prior to its vyAkruta rUpa.
>

Please be on the topic. The anumAna presented by BhAshykAra is simple and
clear. न च घटाभावः सन्पटः अभावात्मकः ; किं तर्हि ? भावरूप एव । एवं घटस्य
प्राक्प्रध्वंसात्यन्ताभावानामपि घटादन्यत्वं स्यात् , घटेन
व्यपदिश्यमानत्वात् , घटस्येतरेतराभाववत् ; तथैव भावात्मकताभावानाम.

I will repeat the question:

1. Is pot-abhAva bhAvarUpa?

2. Is pot-abhAva made of three guNAs namely sattva, rajas and tamas?

Just simple, plain, clear questions.

Regards.
Sudhanshu Shekhar.